Last Updated On: October 31, 2023

Domestic Partnership Vs. Marriage

Navigating the landscape of personal relationships can be complex, especially when it comes to legal commitments like marriage or domestic partnerships. The state of New York, like many others, offers both of these options, each with its own unique set of rights, responsibilities, and implications. The decision to opt for marriage or a domestic partnership is an important one, influencing various aspects of your life, from financial obligations to healthcare decisions and beyond. Understanding the differences, benefits, and potential drawbacks of each can help you make an informed choice that best suits your personal and legal needs.

Whether you’re considering entering into a domestic partnership or tying the knot, it’s crucial to understand the legalities involved. New York City family law attorney Juan Luciano can help guide you through these complexities, ensuring that your rights are protected and that your decisions are well-informed. Don’t navigate these waters alone — contact us today at (212) 537-5859 for tailored legal assistance.

Domestic Partnerships and Marriage in New York

Both domestic partnerships and marriages are legally recognized relationships. However, the rights, benefits, and responsibilities they confer differ significantly.

What is a Domestic Partnership?

In New York, a domestic partnership is a legally recognized relationship that provides some but not all of the benefits of marriage. Domestic partnerships are available to both same-sex and different-sex couples. This relationship is often chosen by couples who are living together but may not wish to or cannot legally get married. 

What is Marriage in New York?

Marriage in New York is defined as a legally binding contract between two people, regardless of gender, under the laws of the state. It’s a formal commitment recognized by both civil and religious law, often celebrated with a ceremony. Married couples are granted a variety of legal rights and benefits, including but not limited to, the ability to make medical decisions for each other, inheritance rights, joint tax filing, and social security benefits. Additionally, marital status offers a level of societal recognition and validation that domestic partnerships may not provide.

Understanding the legal rights and benefits associated with domestic partnerships and marriages can significantly impact a couple’s decision to choose one over the other. While both relationships grant certain legal protections, there are key differences in the extent and nature of these benefits. 

Rights and Benefits of Domestic Partnerships

Upon registering as domestic partners, a couple acquires certain privileges that they wouldn’t otherwise possess. Here are the specific rights granted to couples who register as domestic partners in New York City:

  • Family Leave: City employees who are domestic partners have the right to bereavement and child care leave.
  • Prison Visitation Rights: Domestic partners can visit their partner in a City correctional or juvenile detention facility.
  • Hospital Visitation Rights: Facilities operated by the New York City Health and Hospitals Corporation permit visitations by domestic partners.
  • NYC Housing Privileges: Domestic partners have the eligibility to be recognized as a family member in accordance with New York City Housing Authority rules.
  • Tenancy and Occupancy Rights: The Department of Housing Preservation and Development rules allow domestic partners to be considered as family members with the right to succeed to tenancy or occupancy.
  • Health Benefits: Health benefits are provided to domestic partners by the City of New York.

These rights help to recognize and protect the relationships of domestic partners, ensuring that they are treated fairly and equitably in a variety of important contexts. However, it’s important to note that these rights can differ depending on the county where the partnership is registered. Therefore, couples considering this step should consult a skilled Manhattan family law attorney to understand the specific rights and responsibilities that will apply in their specific location.

Rights and Benefits of Marriage

Marriage, on the other hand, offers more extensive legal rights and benefits than a domestic partnership. These include, but are not limited to:

Tax Benefits

Regardless of personal opinions on the institution of marriage, one cannot deny that it bestows numerous legal and practical advantages. One of these is tax benefits. Married couples are allowed to file joint federal income tax returns with the IRS. Moreover, marriage forms a “family partnership” under federal tax laws, which facilitates the division of business income among family members.

Estate Planning Benefits

Marriage also offers a variety of estate planning benefits. A spouse has the right to inherit a share of their partner’s estate. They also receive an exemption from both estate taxes and gift taxes for all property gifted or left to them by their spouse. Additionally, marriage allows for the creation of life estate trusts, including QTIP trusts, QDOT trusts, and marital deduction trusts, that are restricted to married couples. If a spouse needs a conservator, such as someone to make financial or medical decisions on their behalf, being married ensures priority.

Government Benefits

Marriage also opens up access to numerous government benefits. These include receiving Social Security, Medicare, and disability benefits for spouses. Spouses of veterans and military personnel are eligible for benefits such as education, medical care, or special loans. Marriage also grants eligibility for certain public assistance benefits.

Employment Benefits

There are also specific benefits in employment that marriage provides. For instance, one can obtain insurance benefits through a spouse’s employer. If a spouse falls ill, the other is allowed to take family leave to care for them. In the event of a spouse’s death, the surviving partner is entitled to receive wages, workers’ compensation, and retirement plan benefits. Moreover, a spouse is entitled to take bereavement leave if their partner or one of their partner’s close relatives passes away.

Registration and Requirements

Whether you’re considering a domestic partnership or marriage, it’s important to understand the registration procedures and requirements for each in New York. Both involve specific eligibility criteria and steps that must be followed to be legally recognized. This section delves into the process for both registering a domestic partnership and getting married in the state of New York.

Registering a Domestic Partnership in New York

For couples who choose to solidify their commitment through a domestic partnership, understanding the registration process in New York is key. This includes knowing the eligibility criteria and steps necessary to complete the registration.

Eligibility Criteria

To register a domestic partnership in New York, couples must meet several conditions. Both individuals must be at least 18 years old, not related by blood in a way that would prevent them from being married, live together on a continuous basis, and neither can be married or in a domestic partnership with anyone else.

Registration Process

The process for registering a domestic partnership involves the following steps:

  • Complete the Application: The application for Domestic Partnership Registration can be obtained from the Office of the City Clerk. Both partners must provide accurate information and signatures.
  • Provide Identification: Both partners must present valid identification that shows their name and date of birth. These can include a driver’s license, passport, or birth certificate.
  • Pay the Registration Fee: There is a fee for registering a domestic partnership. The fee must be paid at the time of application.
  • Submit the Application: The completed application, along with the required identification and fee, must be submitted to the Office of the City Clerk.

Getting Married in New York

Couples opting for marriage need to be aware of the specific requirements for obtaining a marriage license in New York. From the initial application to the officiating of the ceremony, each step plays a crucial role in ensuring the legal validity of the union, as outlined in the upcoming subsections.

Marriage License Requirements

Obtaining a marriage license in New York involves a series of steps:

  • Complete the Application: Both parties must appear in person at a City Clerk’s office to complete the application.
  • Wait Period: After receiving the license, there is a mandatory 24-hour waiting period before the marriage ceremony can be performed.
  • Provide Identification and Proof of Age: This can include a driver’s license, passport, or birth certificate.
  • Pay the License Fee: There is a fee for obtaining a marriage license, payable at the time of application.

Marriage Ceremony and Officiants

In New York, a marriage ceremony must be conducted by any of the individuals specified in Section 11 of the Domestic Relations Law. These include, but are not limited to, mayors, city clerks, judges, and ordained or authorized clergy members of any religion.

To sum up, registering a domestic partnership and getting married in New York both require careful adherence to legal processes and requirements. Couples should fully understand these procedures to ensure their union is legally recognized. Consulting with a legal professional can provide clarity and assistance in navigating these processes.

Dissolving a Domestic Partnership

Just as entering a domestic partnership requires legal steps, so does ending one. Dissolving a domestic partnership involves navigating through legal processes, dividing shared assets and debts, and potentially dealing with child custody and support issues. Understanding these aspects can equip individuals with the knowledge they need to handle this challenging situation.

In New York, a domestic partnership can be terminated by filing a Termination Statement in person at the Office of the City Clerk. Both parties do not need to be present, but the party filing must provide identification and pay a termination fee. The termination becomes effective 30 days after the Statement is filed.

However, if the partners have shared property or children, it may be necessary to go to court to dissolve the partnership. In such cases, the process resembles that of a divorce, with a court deciding on the division of assets, child custody, and support.

Division of Assets and Debts

When dissolving a domestic partnership, the division of assets and debts can be challenging, especially if the partners do not agree on the division. While New York law provides some guidelines, they are less clear than for divorces. Generally, any property acquired during the partnership is considered joint property and is divided equally. However, disputes may arise, and it may be necessary to involve a lawyer or mediator.

Debts are also typically divided equally unless one partner can prove that they did not consent to the debt or that it did not benefit the partnership. If an agreement cannot be reached, a court may need to decide on the division of debts.

Child Custody and Support for Domestic Partners

In cases where a domestic partnership involves children, custody and support can be complex issues. In New York, courts decide on child custody based on the best interests of the child, considering factors such as each parent’s ability to provide for the child’s needs, the child’s wishes (if they are old enough), and the stability of each parent’s home environment.

As for child support, the noncustodial parent is typically required to pay support to the custodial parent. The amount of support is determined by a formula that considers the parents’ income, the number of children, and other factors.

Dissolving a domestic partnership involves various legal and practical considerations. It’s advisable for individuals going through this process to seek legal advice to ensure their rights and interests are protected.

Divorce in New York

Ending a marriage legally can be a complex process, deeply interwoven with emotional and financial challenges. In New York, divorce involves understanding the grounds for divorce, navigating the legal process, and dealing with issues like alimony and property division. This section aims to provide a broad understanding of these aspects.

The Divorce Process

The divorce process in New York involves several steps:

  • Filing a Petition: The first step is for one spouse (the plaintiff) to file a complaint or petition for divorce with the court.
  • Serving the Petition: The complaint must be personally delivered (served) to the other spouse (the defendant), who has a specific period to respond.
  • Response by the Defendant: The defendant can agree with the complaint, disagree and file an answer, or fail to respond, in which case the court may grant a default divorce.
  • Negotiation and Trial: If the spouses cannot agree on issues like property division or child custody, they may need to negotiate through their attorneys or go to trial, where a judge will make the decisions.
  • Finalizing the Divorce: Once all issues are resolved, the court issues a divorce decree that legally ends the marriage.

Alimony and Property Division in Divorce

In New York, alimony, also known as spousal support or maintenance, may be awarded to one spouse. The amount and duration of alimony depend on factors such as each spouse’s income and property, the length of the marriage, the age and health of both parties, and the need of one party to incur education or training expenses.

Property division in a New York divorce follows the principles of equitable distribution. This doesn’t necessarily mean a 50/50 split but rather a division that is fair and just. The court considers factors such as the length of the marriage, the age and health of both parties, the income and property of each party, and the needs of the custodial parent to occupy or own the marital residence.

Making the Right Choice

Choosing between a domestic partnership and marriage is a significant decision that impacts several aspects of your life, from legal status to financial implications. Understanding the considerations related to both choices can help you make an informed decision that best aligns with your needs and circumstances. 

Factors to Consider when Choosing Domestic Partnership

When considering a domestic partnership, several factors come into play. These considerations largely revolve around the legal, financial, and personal implications of this choice.

Legal Implications: Domestic partnerships provide some, but not all, of the legal benefits of marriage. For example, in New York, domestic partners have the right to visit each other in the hospital and make some medical decisions. However, on a federal level, domestic partners may not have the same rights as married couples, such as federal tax benefits or Social Security survivor benefits.

Financial Implications: Domestic partnerships do not carry the same financial obligations as marriage. For instance, partners are not legally obligated to support each other financially. However, they may have certain rights to shared property.

Personal Considerations: Choosing a domestic partnership may align better with personal beliefs or values for some. For example, couples may prefer a domestic partnership if they wish to avoid the traditional connotations of marriage or if they want to maintain a level of legal and financial independence.

Factor Domestic Partnership Marriage
Legal Implications Provides some legal benefits but not all. Varies by state. May lack federal benefits. Provides a wide array of legal protections and benefits at both state and federal levels.
Financial Implications Fewer financial obligations; partners aren’t legally obligated to support each other financially. Rights to shared property may apply. Involves legal obligations for financial support. Complex asset and debt division in divorce.
Personal Considerations May align better with personal beliefs or values. Offers legal and financial independence. Societally recognized and accepted. Smoother interactions with institutions.

Factors to Consider when Choosing Marriage

On the other hand, the choice of marriage carries its own set of considerations. These relate to the legal protections, financial obligations, and societal perceptions associated with marriage.

Legal Protections: Marriage provides a wide array of legal protections and benefits, both on a state and federal level. These include automatic inheritance rights, tax advantages, access to health care and retirement benefits, and more.

Financial Obligations: Marriage, unlike a domestic partnership, involves legal obligations for financial support. In addition, the division of assets and debts in a divorce can be more complex and legally defined in a marriage.

Societal Perceptions: Societal recognition and acceptance of marriage can be a significant factor for some people. Marriage is widely recognized and understood, which can make interactions with institutions like hospitals, schools, or insurance companies smoother.

Making the right choice between a domestic partnership and marriage depends largely on personal circumstances, beliefs, and needs. It’s essential to understand the legal and financial implications of each choice, as well as how each aligns with your personal values and life goals. Consulting with a legal professional or a financial advisor can provide valuable insights to help inform your decision.

Getting the Help of an Experienced New York Family Law Attorney

Navigating the complexities of legal relationship commitments like marriage and domestic partnerships can be challenging. Yet, understanding the implications of these choices is crucial to making the best decision for your unique circumstances. Keep in mind that everyone’s situation is different, and what works for one couple may not be the best choice for another.

If you’re making the decision between choosing a domestic partnership or marriage, or if you need legal assistance with dissolving a partnership or a marriage, it’s wise to seek professional advice. Experienced New York City family law attorney Juan Luciano can provide valuable insights and guidance tailored to your specific circumstances. Don’t leave your future to chance; ensure you have the right legal support to make the most informed decision. Contact us today at (212) 537-5859 to schedule a consultation.

Share:
Facebook
Twitter
Pinterest
LinkedIn
On Key
Related Posts
Call Now Button